As the exciting and wonderful
Tournament of Champions proceeds, each Friday I will recap the previous round of action.
However, no one will be reading this website tomorrow. Hell, I'll be lucky if anyone reads it today. So, in order to fill my vainglorious need for attention, we're bumping up the inaugural recap to Thursday, even while the fourth bracket completes its first round of play.
(As we proceed in this recap, it may be helpful to refer to either the
PDF version or the handy-dandy
live version (which updates as votes come in) of the 64 competitor bracket.)
Berryessa Division, Round 1First and foremost, remember that the division names have no relation to the competitors therein. Just to get that out of the way.
- Chuck Reed (1) defeated The Wave (16) 64-34
- Ash Kalra (8) defeated Vic Ajlouny (9) 45-42
- Larry Stone (12) defeated Community Papers (5) 50-46
- Barry Swenson (4) defeated Scott Knies (13) 66-21
- Firefighters (6) defeated Blanca Alvarado (11) 69-18
- Phaedra Ellis-Lamkins (3) defeated Paul Krutko (14) 73-21
- Carl Guardino (7) defeated Kansen Chu (10) 60-26
- Nora Campos (2) defeated Pat Waite (15) 117-67
Only one upset in this division, as a most-likely-underseeded Larry Stone pulls off an upset against an underrespected Community Newspapers, in one of the closest matches of the tournament so far.
The real story here, though, is the monster showing by Nora Campos to shut down the Pat Waite juggernaut. Consider this: Waite's score would have been enough to win five of the other races - and Campos almost
doubled it.
As expected, the 8 seed vs. 9 seed was a close one, with Ash Kalra demonstrating that presumptive-Council-elect is a stronger hand than shadowy-backroom-manipulator.
Last note - Blanca Alvarado does not get much respect. Even Scott Knies got more votes.
What to look for in Round 2: The Larry - Barry fight should be a good one, as we see if the forces that drove a low-seeded Stone to victory can defeat trillions of dollars. And, of course, the battle of union power between Ellis-Lamkins and the firefighters.
Downtown Division, Round 1- Mike Honda (1) defeated Republican Party (16) 75-17
- Vietnamese Activists (8) defeated Elaine Alquist (9) 54-33
- Scott Herhold (5) defeated Nancy Pyle (12) 48-31
- Sam Liccardo (4) defeated Deb Figone (13) 66-22
- Joe Coto (11) defeated Cindy Chavez (6) 84-62
- Dan Fenton (14) defeated Madison Nguyen (3) 63-59
- Pat Dando (7) defeated Dean Munro (10) 42-37
- Ken Yeager (2) defeated San Jose Revealed (15) 55-31
This bracket saw two upsets. The Coto / Chavez race could have gone either way, but Joe got out to an early lead and built on it from there.
But the Nguyen / Fenton race was a shocker. Most of the day, the two were within 10 votes of each other, Madison leading nearly the entire time. This alone is a surprise, as it takes a pretty thorough knowledge of the City to know who Fenton is. But, in the late going, Fenton outpaced Nguyen to creep past by a razor thin margin.
There is, of course, a likely culprit: some of the many folks out there who have expressed dissatisfaction with Nguyen, because of a shopping center or something. (The same folks, incidentally, who beat Elaine Alquist by a healthy margin in the 8 vs. 9 seed game.) But if it were that group, I'd have expected the final to be Fenton 1,062 - Nguyen 8. So who knows?
Another thought: lots of folks in this bracket did better than they should have, probably. Dean Munro nearly beating Dando? The final score is a wider margin than that race saw most of the day. And San Jose Revealed, this humble blog, getting more than half the votes Ken Yeager did? I appreciate the loyalty, but come on. The real surprise, of course: 17 people think the Republican Party has more sway in San Jose than Mike Honda?
What to look for in Round 2: Honda vs. the Vietnamese activists should be a walk, but who knows? We'll look to see if Fenton's success was a protest vote as he takes on Joe Coto. And Yeager / Dando will provide a rematch of their sparring from their City Council days.
Willow Glen Division, Round 1- Tom McEnery (1) defeated Andy Diaz (16) 40-17
- Ira Ruskin (9) defeated Metro (8) 32-30
- Jim Beall (5) defeated Richard Hobbs (12) 45-8
- John Sobrato (4) defeated Redevelopment Agency (13) 32-23
- Democratic Party (6) defeated Jude Barry (11) 40-13
- Lew Wolff (3) defeated Larry Pegram (14) 50-6
- Evil Lobbyists (7) defeated Rose Herrera (10) 43-9
- Zoe Lofgren (2) defeated Judy Chirco (15) 45-8
The same 17 people who think the Republicans out-influence Honda feel the same way about Andy "Abe" Diaz, apparently. And even on a low-voting, getting-ready-for-the-Fourth day, McEnery whupped Diaz. As most of us could have.
The story here, of course, was the great Ruskin / Metro match-up. As befits an 8 vs. 9 match, the battle went back and forth all day, with neither competitor going up by more than three or so, and the two often tied. But usually, when the tie was broken, Ruskin was ahead, as the final results indicate. Farewell, Metro. We'll see you in the funny pages.
But this division was also the division of the smack-down, with Herrera, Chirco, Pegram and Hobbs all getting demolished, ending with single digit scores. Many of their opponents had scores that would have been respectable even on the higher-scoring first day, but these five got smacked. Feel free to read into this however you want. I'm sure Pat Waite will soon release a statement trumpeting his having outscored Herrera by a factor of 7 to 1.
What to look for in Round 2: Probably the most interesting fight here will be Lew Wolff vs. the Democrats. But then, we'll see. We've been surprised before. And, let's be honest - we're all just waiting to see that Lofgren - McEnery 1 vs. 2 match-up for the Final Four, should it come to it.
Almaden Valley Division, Round 1- Mercury News (1) defeated Larry Gerston (16) 36-16
- Forrest Williams (9) defeated Pierluigi Oliverio (8) 31-21
- Susan Hammer (5) defeated Business Journal (12) 29-24
- Bob Kieve (13) defeated Greg Jamison (4) 29-21
- George Shirakawa (11) defeated Pete Constant (6) 35-27
- Dave Cortese (3) defeated Michael Mulcahy (14) 38-12
- Neil Struthers (10) defeated San Jose Inside (7) 40-16
- Police Officers Association (2) defeated David Pandori (15) 47-3
Low voting, sure - but the day before the Fourth resulted in some of the most interesting battles so far, with
four upsets: Williams, Kieve, Shirakawa and Struthers.
Of these, the Kieve / Jamison battle was the most interesting. The two were tied most of the day until Kieve had a late surge, putting him up handily. Mind you on day 1, most of the losers had more votes than Kieve. But no matter - on he goes to Round 2, facing the Susan Hammer powerhouse.
The biggest trouncing so far happened, as I suppose it should, in that 2 vs. 15 battle, as the cops brutalized, tazed, stunned, abused... just plain
dominated David Pandori. Sure, the guy was a Councilmember in the 1930s, and came in third for Mayor but, still. Three votes? Who out there will admit they joined David and McEnery in voting for him?
So next week is Round Two. Feel free to download your
Round 2 bracket as a PDF, and play along at home.
Labels: Tournament of Champions